The surprising hygiene of library books: Why the next thing you read is not a biological hazard

13

We thought of books as sacred objects. When Gutenberg started printing around 1450, ink-dyed paper became a marvel. It educated, entertained and kept us company on rainy evenings. In 18th century America, lending libraries were democratic sanctuaries. Farmers and financiers mingled freely and had free access to information.

Now? We treat them like a mess.

In our device-driven, ephemeral culture, physical books are undervalued. They are thrown in the trash. They land on the curbs. They get thrown in the trash. And that’s why we assume they’re dirty. We assume thousands of sneezing and touching strangers have contaminated every page.

Is that true? Are library books biohazards?

The answer is more complex than a simple “yes” or “no”. And honestly, it’s probably less gross than you think.

From the streets to the archive

Before we worry about germs, we should think about what happens to books when they are discarded.

In Vancouver, British Columbia, in 2017, a homeless man dug through a pile of trash in an alley. He found four rough books bound in morocco leather from the 1870s. Their title was “Far East”. Inside were 24 issues of a rare English-language news magazine published in Shanghai between 1870 and 1878.

This wasn’t just trash. It was a treasure.

Don Stewart, owner of MacLeod’s Books in Vancouver, bought them for an undisclosed price. He called it the best thing he ever pulled out of the trash. For comparison, Sothebys auctioned 118 issues of the same magazine in 2009 for more than $42,000. The market value of these discarded quantities is high. The physical condition was poor, but the historical significance was enormous.

Books don’t always end up in landfills. Sometimes they find a new life.

In Ankara, Turkey, cleaners collected thousands of discarded books. They didn’t bury them. They built a library.

It started small. A collection for employees and their families. But it spread. People donated their discarded shares. By September 2017, the public could enter. It is located in an old brick building in the city’s sanitary headquarters. It now contains 6,000 volumes. It lends books to schools, educational programs and even prisons.

These are not rotting hazards. They are the anchors of the community.

The Science of “Fomite”.

But back to bacteria. You took the book. You read it. Did you just inhale E. coli?

In 2017, Cheyenne Deibert, a 16-year-old high school student in Los Angeles, wondered the same thing. She had the flu. She held a library book. She panicked. Was she getting contagious bacteria all over her nose and hands?

To find out, he launched an award-winning science fair project.

Cheyenne worked with local librarians. She picked popular, high-circulation books. She took swabs. She rubbed them on petri dishes.

She used two types of media.
1. Agar, which promotes the growth of bacteria.
2. Methylene blue, which inhibits certain bacteria and allows others to flourish.

She incubated the plates at body temperature. She waited for results.

The outcome?

Not much bacteria was present. None of the swabs showed E. coli.

Cheyenne Deibert’s project showed that library books are not significant carriers of infectious diseases. The risk is small.

But what’s the technical term for a book that might contain germs?

A fomite.

A fomite is an inanimate object that can spread infectious organisms. Viruses. Bacteria. They jump from person to person over these objects. Books. E-readers. Door handles. All potential fomites.

Jesse T. Jacob, M.D., assistant professor of medicine and hospital epidemiologist at Emory University Hospital Midtown, spoke about this directly.

He said that the risk of infection from books and e-reading devices is very low.

Why the fear persists

We cringe at the thought. We imagine sick people sneezing on the pages. We imagine a chain of transmission. It feels visceral. It feels dangerous.

But the data doesn’t support panic.

Cheyenne Deibert’s research showed minimal microbial growth. Dr. Jacob confirmed the low risk. Still, we treat books like radioactive waste. We throw them away. We reject them. We ignore their value because we fear their dirt.

Is it worth the risk? Probably not. Library book hygiene is better than you think.

Is it perfect? No. No item is sterile.

But consider the alternative. Consider the homeless man in Vancouver who found history in a trash can. Think of the sanitation workers in Ankara who built a library out of garbage. Consider the teenager who proved that germs can be controlled with paper.

Books are tactile. They are real. They are not digital clouds. They sit on shelves. They get read. They get passed along.

Do they carry germs? Yes. Everything does.

Are they dangerous? Not really.

But we stopped caring. We have stopped seeing them as objects of wonder. We see them as clutter. As waste. As something to be thrown away rather than preserved.

Books survive the garbage. They survive the germs. They survive us.

Do we deserve them?

Maybe not. But they continue.

Can you really catch a cold from a book in the library? The short answer is: no, not really. But let’s look at the science behind why your local library is one of the safest places in the world.

Jacob, a consulted expert on the subject, puts it bluntly. Yes, it is possible to get sick from touching a library book. If someone with the flu licks their finger to turn a page or sneezes directly on it, you are looking at a risk. But Jacob calls that “unlikely.”

Here are the details. Influenza remains on paper and cloth for less than 12 hours. Normally, respiratory tract secretions carry the highest viral load. And these secretions are usually not found on spit. So licking your finger to turn a page is actually less contagious than picking your nose and turning a book.

Jacob points out that most respiratory viruses are transmitted through indirect contact. Think doorknobs. Handles. Surfaces that people constantly touch. You touch the object and then your mucous membranes – eyes, nose, mouth. This is a vector. Books and tablets can potentially spread germs. However, for most people it does not cause an infection.

Which bacteria survive best on paper?

When it comes to longevity on paper, not all bugs are created equal. Some bacteria are tougher than others. Gram-positive bacteria, such as streptococci and staphylococci, generally survive better on surfaces. They are followed by viruses.

But here’s the twist. Jacob suggests that if you’re worried about getting sick from a book, you should pay attention to mold and dust. Many people are allergic to it. They are probably bigger problems than bacteria or viruses on the pages.

What should you do?

“Clean your hands and do not touch your face or mucous membranes with potentially contaminated fingers to avoid contracting the virus.”

It’s simple hygiene. Not rocket science.

The irony of old books

If you’re regretting throwing away your dog-eared, pizza-stained copy of the novel that ignited your youthful passion, don’t worry. Visit your local library for another popular copy. The possibility of getting sick from it is very small.

The probability that it will make you happy is very, very high.

It’s interesting.

Arsenic was once known as “inheritance powder”. It could mean curtains for a rich old aunt. But people thought nothing of decorating the walls with wallpaper containing arsenic. It releases potentially deadly dust particles. You could inhale them. You could ingest them.

The pages of “Shadows from the Walls of Death,” published in 1874 by American Civil War-era Union surgeon Robert M. Kedzie, can be fatal if touched without gloves. Kedzie wrote the book to warn people about the dangers of using wallpaper containing arsenic in interior design.

Although hands should be washed after handling old books, you do not need to wear a protective suit. Unless, of course, you’re reading a book about arsenic wallpaper. Then maybe just gloves.